Benky’s Cream & Sugar

Located in the heart of Keystone, South Dakota, Benky’s Cream & Sugar is a delightful ice cream shop that brings a refreshing twist to your classic frozen treats. Nestled at 111 Winter St, this charming spot is a must-visit for locals and tourists craving a sweet haven after a day of exploring the Black Hills region.

Benky’s boasts an impressive lineup of flavors, featuring 18 varieties of hard ice cream alongside luscious soft serve options, sundaes, and indulgent shakes. One of their standout delights is the homemade tub ice cream, perfected for that ideal scoop which customers rave about. From the nostalgic bubblegum flavor—a rare find that instantly transports you back to childhood—to the creamy cookies and cream, each bite offers a rich, velvety texture and balanced sweetness that feels both comforting and exciting.

The atmosphere at Benky’s Cream & Sugar is refreshingly cozy and inviting. Whether you choose to sit inside in a clean, well-kept environment or enjoy the fresh air with seating outside, the ambiance perfectly complements the casual, friendly vibe of the shop. The staff are consistently praised for their warm and attentive service, making each visit feel personal and welcoming. It’s clear that customer experience is a top priority here, adding a layer of charm that keeps people coming back.

What truly sets Benky’s apart is their thoughtful touches—like a $1 special treat for your dog, ensuring no family member is left out of the fun. Sundaes, including fan favorites like the Gold Rush, arrive huge and attractively assembled, ready to satisfy your sweet tooth or share with friends. Some customers note the sundaes are packed with sweetness and perfectly portioned, while others mention a desire for slightly better ingredient distribution—showing an honest, authentic approach to growth and feedback.

Beyond just ice cream, Benky’s also offers a selection of salt water taffies and candies, adding variety for those who want a little extra sugar fix. The shop strikes a wonderful balance between feeling classic and polished, elevating the typical tourist zone experience without pretension.

Whether you’re in Keystone on vacation or just passing through, Benky’s Cream & Sugar delivers a reliably delicious and heartwarming ice cream experience. With flavors to satisfy every craving, attentive service, and a welcoming atmosphere, it’s no surprise that visitors consistently rate Benky’s as the best spot around. Treat yourself—you deserve it.